Showing posts with label defaulters. Show all posts
Showing posts with label defaulters. Show all posts

Friday, March 27, 2015

Can FTIL’s Proposed Solution Crack NSEL Logjam?

Often the solution is easy and lies before our eyes, and yet we do not see it. We move mountains and cross oceans, and yet all the while the remedy was lying in plain sight in our own courtyard.

This is what is happening with the  NSEL issue. If all the stakeholders—FTIL, the trading clients, brokers, and the government— join hands, the payment default crisis at NSEL can be speedily resolved. In fact, FTIL’s proposed solution as outlined to the government can heal the wounds of all the stakeholders inflicted by the defaulters on NSEL’s trading platform.

In a manner of speaking, the solution would entail that the pain is evenly distributed. The money trail to the last paisa has been found with the defaulters and they should be held accountable for their actions. So far, without any reason, it is only FTIL that has borne the brunt of the crisis by facing various proceedings which are sub-judice.

The privity of contract of the trading clients is with the brokers. It is brokers which have made multi-times money while transacting on the exchange. It is therefore important that they participate in the settlement process to enable payment to trading clients.

According to Business Standard, published on March 20, Prashant Desai, the Managing Director & CEO of FTIL, said, “FTIL proposes to pay Rs. 500 crore, of which Rs. 180 crore was already paid in 2013, with the brokers contributing equally”.  The proposed solution is without prejudice and is subjected to FTIL shareholder and board approval.

If all the parties concerned agree to implement it with government help, all trading clients with exposure of up to Rs. 1 crore, which are 11, 954 in number, will get at least half their dues as reported in the Business Standard article. The PSUs will receive 100% of their claims.  

Mr. Venkat Chary, the chairman of the FTIL, too had reiterated that “around 94% of trading clients’ claims can be immediately addressed in part or full measure by Rs.1, 000 crore payment.” 

Eleven defaulters have admitted liability of Rs 2,000 crore and high court has issued decrees for Rs 513 crore.

If all parties contribute and come forward to resolve the NSEL issue, then it will be one less problem for the government to solve.  

Tuesday, December 23, 2014

Extended to yet ‘Next’ – NSEL - FTIL merger proceeds will stay as is where is - till Feb 4.

Status quo continues. Bombay HC has extended the stay on government’s NSEL-FTIL merger order till 4 February, 2015.

Perhaps new hopes elevated; the position is still as it is where it was; if it will mark a sublime beginning of the conclusion, is the question. Contrary to the unanimous views that emanated from a vast majority of the business fraternity and media spigots, the government has been steadfast in calling for an unwarranted merger of NSEL with FTIL, on 23 October, 2014. This caused a maelstrom of happenings all over, quaking business moorings and economy at large.

As scheduled, the hearing took place on 22 December, 2014, before Justice VM Kanade. The NSEL Investors Forum (NIF) was issued a notice for contempt of court; as the said forum had made allegations against the said Justice that he could be biased as his son had appeared for a nominee director of PD Agroprocessors, who is one of the defaulters in NSEL.

Who’s to judge whose integrity? Has faith in the judiciary among people dwindled, or is it just prejudicing to doubt eminence? But to affirm that justice is alive and omnipotent, the faith of both Forward Markets Commission’s (FMC) and Ministry of Corporate Affair’s (MCA) counsels in the judge was evident and audible in the court. They confirmed their acquiescence to it, reflecting their conviction and trust when they were asked if they had any objection, by the judge offering to recuse himself, if they had any.

On previous hearings, FTIL’s counsel Abhishek Manu Singhvi contended saying that the draft order for the amalgamation was issued under section 396 of the Companies Act and extended his argument stating that the merger needs to be approved by the boards of both the companies in question, along with the approval of ROC and Official Liquidator’s (OL) nod.

With hindsight, it was a recommendation by FMC and the department of economic affairs that triggered a shockwave which was followed by the government’s draft order for merger. The aim maybe to haste the merger, but it is, as debated all over, bound to dilapidate the scene adversely, and it is inimical for the economy and entrepreneurial growth at large. FTIL’s argument has been that the uncalled-for amalgamation will unavoidably transfer the default of NSEL to FTIL.


The fallout will prove to be "wet blanket" resulting in haplessness, plaguing the scene with waning interest among existing stakeholders, employees of the parent company, besides dismaying new investors across-the-board.