Showing posts with label Ministry of Finance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ministry of Finance. Show all posts
Sunday, November 16, 2014
Tuesday, November 11, 2014
NSEL-FTIL merger proposal- Standards ruptured. How Satyam case is different from FTIL’s.
Appalling ideas
wished-for, to further impose on FTIL! Earlier, it was the proposed idea of NSEL-FTIL
merger by Forward Markets Commission, which was subsequently ordered by the
Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA); then taking possession of FTIL management
has been on government’s anvil. Now, is it just getting arms over resources or
getting the claws into the healthily operational organisation, for which the
activism is being sped up?
“The government owes the nation an
explanation as to why and on what grounds the Forward Markets Commission (FMC)
has been making these proposals to breach FTIL’s limited liability……..”(Source – EconomicTimes, Oct. 28, 2014. Edit, PageNo.16).
Would there be a
tenable reasoning to all that the nation is looking up for. Also, suggests the
excerpts of the Economic Times’ edit page titled “Who’s Targeting FTILBreaching all Norms?”It reads as –“It is
entirely unwarranted to do a Satyam on FTIL, on the pretext of speeding up the
process of recovery from the defaulting traders of NSEL.
The government owes the nation an explanation as to
why and on what grounds the Forward Markets Commission(FMC)has been making
these proposals to breach FTIL’s limited liability when no wrongdoing or improper
pecuniary gain has yet been established against its management and when there
are clearly identified defaulters who carried out trades with non-existent underlying
stocks and whose obligation to pay is beyond dispute? And why have the
ministries of law and corporate affairs been indulging in these patently
misconceived demands by the FMC?”
As it has been
talked on countless forums that the Economic Offences Wing (EOW) has identified
and frozen the assets of the defaulters and a panel has been set up by the
Bombay High Court for recovery, what’s the panic to merge and take over all about?
But what’s more stroppy is that the hounding actions taken on Satyam are being
proposed for FTIL.
Straightforwardly, these are two diverse gears! There are contrasting events in both the cases, thus no parity can be
drawn between the two. FTIL’s case cannot be labelled as a corporate scandal.
Here are some contrasting
reasons as to how FTIL’s case is far different from Satyam’s, in detail:
Firstly, in the case of Satyam, the promoter had confessed in
writing to the regulator of his wrong-doings, whereas there was vehement and consistent denial by the promoter of
FTIL, of any wrong-doings whatsoever. The matter of his culpability is
sub-judice. Also, the question whether NSEL itself is liable for the
trading losses incurred by the 13,000 clients of the brokers who traded on the
NSEL platform for higher returns (“Trading Clients”) is currently sub-judice
before the Bombay High Court. Hence, the
question of FTIL being held liable through piercing the corporate veil does not
arise.
Secondly, Satyam’s promoter confessed siphoning-off the company’s
funds to his realty firm Maytas infra. Whereas in the case of FTIL, even after 12 months of investigation byEOW, ED and CBI, not a single paisa of the Trading Clients’ money traced eitherto NSEL, Mr. Jignesh Shah or FTIL. On the contrary, the entire money of the
Trading Clients (i.e. Rs. 5,500 Crores) has been traced to 22 Defaulters who
used that for repaying loans, working capital requirements, real estate and
luxury cars. In fact, 85% of the Trading
Clients’ money is with just 7 Defaulters. Both the above aspects confirmed
by the Bombay High Court’s Order of 22 August 2014 granting bail to Mr. Jignesh
Shah.
Thirdly,
Satyam’s promoter confessed fudging of books of account of Satyam. But
in FTIL’s case, No major irregularities found in the ROC’s
inspection of FTIL. FTIL audited by one of the Big-4 accounting firms which has
not found any irregularities in FTIL’s accounts so far. Further, no loan
defaults by FTIL till date have been found. FTIL was granted licenses to set up
exchanges by Indian regulators (such as SEBI, CERC, FMC) and overseas
regulators such as Singapore, Dubai, Mauritius, Bahrain etc. after thorough
due-diligence and background check of the company and its promoters.
Thus, in the
case of Satyam, there was a fraud in the company (i.e. Satyam) itself perpetrated
by the promoters who were also in management. Hence, the remedy was to change
the management- whereas in the case of
FTIL, no fraud has been detected by the courts or investigating agencies. It
is a case of payment and settlement defaults at FTIL’s
subsidiary NSEL due to the 22 Defaulters failing to honor their pay-in
obligations towards NSEL. Hence, the
remedy lies in chasing these Defaulters and ensuring recovery of the Trading
Clients’
monies from them.
In spite of all that, the actions are planned to
be cuffed on FTIL. The sanctity of limited liability is expected to hobble with
such actions, and it’s been time and again voiced out by numerous media houses.
‘Coming up good times’, as the colloquial more coined now and then - will it
see the times when norms and laws are not violated, and also, the rights and ‘limited
liability’ privileges of the investors across-the-board are protected, by
even-handed outlook.
Friday, November 7, 2014
Wednesday, November 5, 2014
Unprecedented Shocker - NSEL-FTIL merger
NSEL – FTIL
amalgamation is supposed to be an unnerving move for all, juddering
establishments and tenets of law - particularly, the Companies Act. Outnumbering
excerpts of myriad media releases and stories have been of the view, and have
articulately indicated that frequently.
As one in the Business World editor’s
note reads as - “As per the order of the
Ministry of Corporate Affairs, NSEL will have to merge with FTIL and lose its
existence. As a result, FTIL will have to bear the consequences of the Rs 5,574-crore
fraud. The owners of the remaining 55 per cent will also bear the brunt. This goes against the fundamentals of limited
liability. The reason so many companies register themselves as ‘limited’ is
because shareholder’s liability is limited to the investment in the company.” Most in the business and media realm are crestfallen by the move. Beyond
principles, the most startling side is how a limited company can be liable for
another company’s liabilities.
Clearly, the
shockwave is unprecedented for various reasons. First - the legal proceeds
ascertained that there has been no trail of money leading to the promoters of
the company. Second - It is also seen as a pre-judgement of Bombay High Court’s
order, wherein the case is still being pursued, and the matter is sub-judice. Third
- As the whole pursuit has been for recovery of trading clients’ monies,
recently a historic order was passed by the Bombay High Court to form a
3-member committee that will determine the assets of the defaulters - this,
obviously, came as a reprieve for the trading clients of NSEL. Thus the merger
call by the MCA defeats the fundamental edifice of limited liability which is
the basic principle of company law; as the law has been laid down to ensure
limited liabilities are efficiently and impeccably managed.
“As per the order of the Ministry of
Corporate Affairs, NSEL will have to merge with FTIL and lose its existence. As
a result, FTIL will have to bear the consequences of the Rs 5,574-crore fraud.
The owners of the remaining 55 per cent will also bear the brunt.
This goes against the fundamentals
of limited liability. The reason so many companies register themselves as
‘limited’ is because shareholder’s liability is limited to the investment in
the company.” (Source –Editor’s Note, Business World)
Experts may be
of the opinion that the move may inflate the potential of raising questions at
the country’s highest court - ‘if the
law is being abided by’ or being bent based on bureaucrats’ decisions? If yes,
then the merit of law perhaps is being subverted out of prejudices. Then, for
sure, it can be said as ‘the off beam precedent’ will undermine the sanctity of
the ‘limited liability.’
Monday, November 3, 2014
FTIL - NSEL Merger – A marring move
In the wake of
government’s proposal to revamp FTIL board following its order to merge NSEL with
FTIL last week, the business community at large cedes it to be starkly
unsavoury. The move has been debated on various media mouthpieces calling it
unwarranted or “a bad precedent.” It
has been countered by FTIL maintaining all the while that all efforts
pertaining to recovery are being diligently escalated. Also, FTIL is a
healthily functional company with the strength of over 1000 employees and over
60,000 shareholders; therefore, persecuting FTIL will be prejudiced and
uncalled-for, for expediting recovery from the defaulters.
The outcry has
gone unheard, and the merger proposed by Forward Market Commission (FMC) is
believed to culminate, making all those who haven’t invested for it bear the brunt
of liability. The massively voiced standpoint ‘why to foist one’s liability on
the other’ has gone unheeded. The merger will not only have a tumbling impact
on the tradition of limited liability - mainly, on the corporate India, but it
will also discourage investors from investing in various portfolios, impacting
the economy adversely. It is also viewed as the nosedive of defaulters to the
extent of duping trading clients is being ignored, besides disregarding FTIL’s
diligent recovery efforts.
What’s more thwarting
is that there’s no charge against the company itself, with no trace of fund
squandering even to the promoters, yet the move has been initiated. Needless to
say, the sanctity of the bourse and markets is being imperilled, setting a
wrong precedent. On various occasions during the proceeds of the case, Bombay
HC’s observation on some portraying as traders, being sceptical about their
legitimacy as traders has been emphasised time and again, which has also been
utterly condoned.
More precisely,
Limited Liability of a parent company determines the amount of money and
resources the company has invested in its subsidiary company; this emerges as
the straightforward norm of modern financial officialdom, which is seen as
being “violated and forsaken” and, principally, believed to send wrong
indication to present and future investors. Thus, it will have a surging effect
on the economy, as the ‘limited liability’ model is an indispensable offshoot
to propel entrepreneurship and investment.
It
is commonly viewed that a small section of trading clients claiming their
money may not constitute a vast majority of people, thus the parity of ‘public
interest’ action is far from being apt to the Companies Act provision,
especially, in this scenario. The protection of public interest mechanism is
equally workable across-the-board; therefore, safeguarding interests of parent
company’s shareholders, employees and stakeholders at large is as much
essential, which is being overlooked. As a result, to protect a handful of
brokers of the crisis-hit NSEL, staking a colossal cluster of 60,000 investors
and over 1000 employees of FTIL, is simply based on a decision of the
bureaucracy. How far it is wise to substitute FTIL’s stakeholders’ liabilities
and interests for NSEL’s, needs a relook, and a popular perspective.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


